| Abstract | Patterns of expressive dynamics were measured in bars 1–5 of 115 commercially recorded performances of Chopin’s Etude in E major, op. 10, No. 3. The grand average pattern (or dynamic
profile)was representative of many performances and highly similar to the average dynamic profile
of a group of advanced student performances, which suggests a widely shared central norm of
expressive dynamics. The individual dynamic profiles were subjected to principal components
analysis, which yielded five Varimax-rotated components, each representing a different, nonstandard dynamic profile associated with a small subset of performances. Most performances
had dynamic patterns resembling a mixture of several components, and no clustering of performances into distinct groups was apparent. Some weak relationships of dynamic profiles with
sociocultural variables were found, most notably a tendency of female pianists to exhibit a greater
dynamic range in the melody. Within the melody, there were no significant relationships between
expressive timing [Repp, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 104, 1085–1100 (1998) and expressive dynamics.
These two important dimensions seem to be controlled independently at this local level and thus
offer the artist many degrees of freedom in giving a melody expressive shape. |